Revs. Pierce M. Comeford, 1878-89 (First Pastor of Saint Joseph); Thomas Phillips, 1889-99; Michael O'Riordan 1899-1905; Francis X. Morrison 1905-21; Thomas J. Brennan 1921-51; Patrick J. Galvan 1951-68; Rev. Msgr. Bernard J. Moran, administrator 1968-70; Revs. Patrick Kearney 1970-73; William J. O'Donnell 1973-95; George E. Crespin 1995-2005; Jayson J. Landeza, Parochial Administrator 2005-06; Stephan Kappler, Parochial Administrator 2006-2007, Pastor 2007-09; John E. Direen 2009-2014; Kenneth Nobrega Parochial Administrator 2014-2021; John C. Prochaska 2021-Present